Translate this Page
Recent reviews :
- Great Naval Battles of the Pacific War (John Grehan)
- Fighting with the Long Range Desert Group (Brendan O'Carroll)
- The Knights of Islam. The Wars of the Mamluks 1250-1517 (James Waterson)
- Wellington's Waterloo Allies (Andrew W. Field)
- The Shetland 'Bus' (Stephen Wynn)
- Peninsular and Waterloo General (Marcus de la Poer Beresford )
- Naval Battles of the Second World War (Leo Marriott)
- Running the Gauntlet (Bernard Edwards)
- Armoured Warfare in the British Army 1914-1939 (Dick Taylor)
- Task Force 58 (Rod Macdonald)
Review for The Great Waterloo Controversy.
Author/Director : Gareth Glover
Format : Book
Another classic Gareth Glover about the battle of Waterloo but this book is firmly focussed on the 52nd Foot. There is a little about the regiment prior to the battle and slightly more about them up to the end of their time in France after the fall of Paris. The 52nd became the Oxfordshire & Buckinghamshire Light Infantry notably going in gliders to hold Pegasus bridge on D-day, WW2.
The controversy referred to in the title is around the defeat of the Imperial Guard in the final stages of the battle. So many accounts present the myth that it was the foot guards alone who achieved this. Glover expertly and conclusively destroys the myth, explaining on the way how it came into existence, and replaces it with the best available evidence of what really happened. The author qualifies his reliance on first-hand accounts by the nearness in time to the event that the account was written and the proximity to the action of the various writers. A large part of the accounts are included in the text. The last two chapters and the appendices are an excellent summary of what is in effect a mass of primary data.
There are some useful maps, a nice set of photographs and an extensive bibliography.
We highly recommend this book which, as well as being a jolly good read, is also a lesson in battle history writing.
Published by : Frontline Books, 2020
ISBN : 978 1 52678 885 6
Review last updated : 2021-08-27 09:26:07
